Forums > Sailing General

Navionics v CMAP v Lighthouse

Reply
Created by cammd 8 months ago, 31 May 2024
cammd
QLD, 4003 posts
31 May 2024 8:56AM
Thumbs Up

Been to the boat show and decided to pull the trigger on a shiny new Axiom MFD as the old C120 is out of date, its just being used as a Radar/AIS screen now.

Got to decide on the charts to go in the new Axiom, any opinions or experience on the three choices above. I am familiar with Navionics but not the other two.

ps. any one after a radar set up, will be selling the current one cheap

woko
NSW, 1631 posts
31 May 2024 9:24AM
Thumbs Up

Can it support AUS ENC ?

cammd
QLD, 4003 posts
31 May 2024 9:36AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
woko said..
Can it support AUS ENC ?


I don't think so, I have them on Open CPN I think, there is entire section of SEQ between Russell Isl and Runaway Bay that is just blank, Its a tricky area for yachts as well.

The advice from O-charts was buy a Brownies beacon to beacon

woko
NSW, 1631 posts
31 May 2024 9:59AM
Thumbs Up

The Clarence river is also only covered by official charts as far upstream as the Harwood bridge, I assume the area you're referring to is also beyond the reach of commercial shipping. I imagine / hope that with the increased ability of digital mapping lesser channels will be charted

cammd
QLD, 4003 posts
31 May 2024 10:11AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
woko said..
The Clarence river is also only covered by official charts as far upstream as the Harwood bridge, I assume the area you're referring to is also beyond the reach of commercial shipping. I imagine / hope that with the increased ability of digital mapping lesser channels will be charted




Yes, that was the reason O-charts gave for the missing navigational information, that area would have to be one of the busiest areas in the country for recreational boating.

Bananabender
QLD, 1603 posts
31 May 2024 12:00PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
cammd said..

woko said..
The Clarence river is also only covered by official charts as far upstream as the Harwood bridge, I assume the area you're referring to is also beyond the reach of commercial shipping. I imagine / hope that with the increased ability of digital mapping lesser channels will be charted





Yes, that was the reason O-charts gave for the missing navigational information, that area would have to be one of the busiest areas in the country for recreational boating.


There is no admiralty chart for that area

cammd
QLD, 4003 posts
31 May 2024 12:59PM
Thumbs Up

Its very poor that the Australian Hydrographic Office have zero interest in that area, as I mentioned it is a very busy waterway that is in the middle of Gold Coast, probably the largest regional city in the country.

Anyway lucky for brownies beacon to beacon and also Navionics, which is what I have opted for on the Axiom.

Chookfoot
QLD, 35 posts
2 Jun 2024 10:52AM
Thumbs Up

Just put O-Charts on my new OpenCPN/Openplotter setup, I'm disappointed to find the lack of detail around Jumpinpin as it is where I do 90% of my sailing. I have made some raster charts for the area using Sat2Chart. better than nothing.

Bananabender
QLD, 1603 posts
2 Jun 2024 1:06PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Chookfoot said..
Just put O-Charts on my new OpenCPN/Openplotter setup, I'm disappointed to find the lack of detail around Jumpinpin as it is where I do 90% of my sailing. I have made some raster charts for the area using Sat2Chart. better than nothing.

I have some great sailing out of HS every week or so . What I did years ago and still refer to for around that area from time to time was to print-off the relevant pages of Beacon to Beacon ,buy a $25 laminator and laminate them to have in the cockpit. The laminator has come in handy for other stuff to leave on board as well.

cammd
QLD, 4003 posts
3 Jun 2024 9:05AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Chookfoot said..
Just put O-Charts on my new OpenCPN/Openplotter setup, I'm disappointed to find the lack of detail around Jumpinpin as it is where I do 90% of my sailing. I have made some raster charts for the area using Sat2Chart. better than nothing.


I have got to learn how to do that.

jbarnes85
VIC, 295 posts
4 Jun 2024 7:34AM
Thumbs Up

I have an axiom with navionics. I have used C-map charts on the iPad via the app as well at the navionics app. I prefer the look of the c-map charts and the information they display (like light characteristics). But the community edits on navionics are great, like people's feedback about anchorages, and these carry accross to the charplotter with your free one year subscription with the SD card when you buy it.

cammd
QLD, 4003 posts
5 Jun 2024 10:04AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
jbarnes85 said..
I have an axiom with navionics. I have used C-map charts on the iPad via the app as well at the navionics app. I prefer the look of the c-map charts and the information they display (like light characteristics). But the community edits on navionics are great, like people's feedback about anchorages, and these carry accross to the charplotter with your free one year subscription with the SD card when you buy it.


I got steered towards the navionics charts, probably because the retailer isn't a B&G dealer. The C-Map looked nice, I had a good look at the B&G screens as well at the show. Hard to split the difference, I like that you could add a forward facing sonar with the B&G Zues that you can't with the Axiom. I ended sticking with Raymarine because it works with all the equipment in the boat already so I don't have to upgrade the entire system at once. The only functionality I wont have is using the Chartplotter to control the auto pilot, I think that is probably a good thing. I don't want the chart plotter having a brain fart or a guest on board deciding to push buttons and gybe the boat by surprise.

Andrew68
VIC, 430 posts
5 Jun 2024 2:20PM
Thumbs Up

I think its good to go with the same brand especially if your wind and depth is also Raymarine. I've previously had trouble getting all the data that is available on Raymarine Seatalkng to B&G equipment.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Sailing General


"Navionics v CMAP v Lighthouse" started by cammd