Forums > Windsurfing   Gps and Speed talk

FangyFin DIY help, hints and show us ya fin page

Reply
Created by fangman > 9 months ago, 29 Oct 2017
fangman
WA, 1774 posts
20 Oct 2020 8:07PM
Thumbs Up


Courtesy of Peter (Waricle) the first batch of titanium barrel nuts.
On the plus side - Very light, very strong and approx 9mm (3/8") so we can use these where space is limited.
On the downside - the galvanic reaction with the aluminium maybe be an issue ( the Aluminium is the anode and will corrode). They will also be expensive compared to the standard brass nuts - possibly twice the price.
On to the testing...!! And then I will let you know whether its worth pursuing
Thank you again Peter




elmo
WA, 8775 posts
21 Oct 2020 6:26AM
Thumbs Up

G'day Ross,
do you want the bad news or the bad news regarding Titanium
l-36.com/corrosion.php


The further apart things are on the galvanic table the more the items at the top corrode, Titanium's pretty much is as bad as it gets.

You would be better of with standard brass.

Realistically the best option is a Marine grade aluminum, it will be a bit soft so over tightening may be an issue but galvanic corrosion will not be one of them.

The other option to stop the corrosion is go to a boating shop and get a zinc annode
www.theboatwarehouse.com.au/boat-building-maintenance/anodes/zinc-solid-round-rod-anodes/
drill a hole in the base fit a piece of zinc into it and corrosion problem fixed

olskool
QLD, 2455 posts
21 Oct 2020 10:29AM
Thumbs Up

Anyone used Duralac to isolate the barrel nut from the alloy?

fangman
WA, 1774 posts
21 Oct 2020 10:02AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
elmo said..
G'day Ross,
do you want the bad news or the bad news regarding Titanium
l-36.com/corrosion.php

The further apart things are on the galvanic table the more the items at the top corrode, Titanium's pretty much is as bad as it gets.

You would be better of with standard brass.

Realistically the best option is a Marine grade aluminum, it will be a bit soft so over tightening may be an issue but galvanic corrosion will not be one of them.

The other option to stop the corrosion is go to a boating shop and get a zinc annode
www.theboatwarehouse.com.au/boat-building-maintenance/anodes/zinc-solid-round-rod-anodes/
drill a hole in the base fit a piece of zinc into it and corrosion problem fixed


Yes the corrosion issue was the thinking behind the Delrin nuts (which worked superbly from that POV) Recently, I have been epoxy-ing the brass barrel nuts in place, and while the fins are dry/no bolt left in situ, the insulating effect of the epoxy seems to be quite effective - and at this stage, provides a durable/strong solution that I think is the most cost effective. ( The stainless steel ones are very good too, but hard to source)
The real problem is I can't resist a bit of boffinising and an experiment or two just to see what happens...

fangman
WA, 1774 posts
21 Oct 2020 10:05AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
olskool said..
Anyone used Duralac to isolate the barrel nut from the alloy?


I did not know about this stuff - looks like it might be the ducks nuts

remery
WA, 3384 posts
21 Oct 2020 1:50PM
Thumbs Up

But renowned metalurgist Robby Naish says that he uses titanium bolts for less corrosion resistance with aloominum...

?t=173

fangman
WA, 1774 posts
21 Oct 2020 2:48PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
remery said..
But renowned metalurgist Robby Naish says that he uses titanium bolts for less corrosion resistance with aloominum...

?t=173


Hmmm, maybe Robbie is talking about 'marketing' type of corrosion. Or perhaps there is something else going on that I don't yet understand - mind you, he does have his cap on backwards...

Imax1
QLD, 4863 posts
21 Oct 2020 7:29PM
Thumbs Up

I think people worry too much . Has anyone had a Fangy fin that has exploded with corrosion ?
I pack mine away wet and I only get slight crusty white dots which brush off , ( 10 sec ) , with a scratchy pad . At this rate of corrosion I should be OK for the next 5 years before I need to sand it . No issues around the brass barrel nut.

fangman
WA, 1774 posts
21 Oct 2020 6:10PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Imax1 said..
I think people worry too much . Has anyone had a Fangy fin that has exploded with corrosion ?
I pack mine away wet and I only get slight crusty white dots which brush off , ( 10 sec ) , with a scratchy pad . At this rate of corrosion I should be OK for the next 5 years before I need to sand it . No issues around the brass barrel nut.


The worst I have had was a Bunnings brass barrel nut stripping its thread. The brass turned out to be plain steel with a very thin 'brass' coating. Doh! Lesson learned.

waricle
WA, 734 posts
21 Oct 2020 9:44PM
Thumbs Up

The thinking behind using titanium is that it offers an alternative to brass or bronze, is a little stronger, is very compatible to the stainless screws and will not corrode the thread of the nut over time. The incompatibility of the titanium to aluminium alloy can be mitigated by the application of a suitable insulator between the nut and the fin as olschool has suggested. Something like an epoxy enamel or similar. The result should be a stronger nut more reliable over time. It also will not risk galling and seizing which is a real possibility using a stainless barrel nut. The ideal would be a titanium fin but is obviously unrealistic from a cost point. Worth a try I reckon.

olskool
QLD, 2455 posts
22 Oct 2020 5:49AM
Thumbs Up

Have used Duralac extensively in marine industry. Great for preventing galvanic reaction. Have seen it last 8yrs or more on painted alloy where stainless fastenings used. No corrosion.
On the same hull ,same grade screw into painted alloy.No Duralac. Bad corrosion after 12months. Cab of boat needed repaint. All bcoz someone DIDNT take that extra step n Duralac a few fittings.
Sure its messy to use n sticks to everything, leaving its telltale pale yellow mark. But well worth the pain.
$30 tube of Duralac or $8k repaint 2 years down the track?

remery
WA, 3384 posts
22 Oct 2020 11:52AM
Thumbs Up

I had a stainless screw into a Naish foil fuselage bind up so bad after a couple of years that it snapped. It was an ordeal getting the remains out and cleaning the thread. I put it back together with Tefgel. My new foil has titanium screws into aluminium fuse, it will be interesting to see which works best.

fangman
WA, 1774 posts
22 Oct 2020 12:27PM
Thumbs Up

As a follow up on Elmo's anode post previously, I was given what I think is an excellent idea by a FF owner yesterday ( if you are concerned about corrosion). Buy some small zinc galvanised self tappers. Drill them into the base somewhere and then grind off the head - super cheap and easy sacrificial anode!

elmo
WA, 8775 posts
26 Oct 2020 4:31PM
Thumbs Up

I had a thought (another poor lonely little thing it was).

Are these fins hollow? is the fin based recessed?

If so just paint then simply these inner surfaces with cold galvanizing paint, couple of good thick coats and you now have a anode attached providing it gets wet

fangman
WA, 1774 posts
27 Oct 2020 3:28PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
elmo said..
I had a thought (another poor lonely little thing it was).

Are these fins hollow? is the fin based recessed?

If so just paint then simply these inner surfaces with cold galvanizing paint, couple of good thick coats and you now have a anode attached providing it gets wet


That seems like a very nice and simple solution Elmo. I will pick up some paint and try that just to see what happens. As alluded to by Imax, I am not sure if anyone has actually had a problem with corrosion yet, but if it ever surfaces as in issue it's good to know we might have some potential easy fixes on hand.
Just as a side note - the FF 18V2 test fins will be solid. The production fins will be hollow if the foundry can find the sweet spot of hollow size vs failure rate/casting shrinkage distortion. The hollow is so physically small and narrow on this fin, it maybe a case of the hassles of saving a few grams outweigh the benefits.

olskool
QLD, 2455 posts
10 Jan 2021 4:51PM
Thumbs Up

Howdy Fangsters! Got my FF28 n FF24 way back in October 20.
Finally made time to get a start. We are running out of water at GB. Silting up everywhere. So I need some shallow running fins.
Anyway I first attacked it with 40grit then 80grit flapper disc. Next was 180grit wet n dry. Then 360 grit wet n dry. Finished with wet green scourer. Any need to take it further?
Setting mine up for Tuttle n PB. In my enthusiasm to fit it to the boards ive removed the location marks for the Brass barrel nuts. Doh!!
Anyone got some dimensions?

olskool
QLD, 2455 posts
11 Jan 2021 12:32PM
Thumbs Up

No reply? Hmmmm...Cmon Fangsters.
How far down from PB housing does barrel nut go?
My issue is coz ive cut fin head to suit PB the rear barrel nut for Tuttle won't have enough meat above it when screwed into board.

mr love
VIC, 2376 posts
11 Jan 2021 2:12PM
Thumbs Up

PB and Tuttle are really different..PB has tapered side walls and tuttle parallel so how are you ging to make it work in both?

olskool
QLD, 2455 posts
11 Jan 2021 1:45PM
Thumbs Up

Easy. Fangy fins bear on the fillet flange n rely on the bolts to hold, not on fin head in board recess.
So cut finhead to PB shape n taper as per PB.
It'll easily fit in Tuttle.
Use 2 barrel nuts in Tuttle position with rear one lower(closer to fin tip) than standard Tuttle.
1 barrel nut for standard PB position. Will hafta use longer rear screw than standard for Tuttle.
So 10mm alloy above barrel nut?

remery
WA, 3384 posts
11 Jan 2021 12:01PM
Thumbs Up

I use my FF22 in both Powerbox and Tuttle. I made a real mess.of drilling the Tuttle holes. Also the barrel nuts I ended up using had to be ground down quite a lot. I used an extra long screw straight into the aluminium for the PB.

olskool
QLD, 2455 posts
11 Jan 2021 2:11PM
Thumbs Up

^ Thanks Remery. Hmmm.. I hadn't thought that the barrel nuts would end up too thick for PB/Tuttle application. Lucky ive drilled no holes yet.
Guess if I put barrel nuts closer to mounting flange it'll cut down the amount of grinding needed.
Also need longer Fangyfin specific bolts for each board.
All good thanks!

mr love
VIC, 2376 posts
11 Jan 2021 3:50PM
Thumbs Up

Yep get it..not relying on the side of the fin box for support.

fangman
WA, 1774 posts
11 Jan 2021 12:59PM
Thumbs Up

Oops! Sorry Olskool I was asleep at the wheel again. In universal box preps, after some experimentation, I now place all my barrel nuts close to the fillet end. This gives the thickest base section and least lateral torque action on the bolt. Also, the amount of width reduction required on your barrel nut is kept to an absolute minimum.( you will still probably need to do some width reduction because the PB Is still a smidge narrower at the base)


Bolt hole location - if you don't have a jig: Tuttle - Place the fin in your board and carefully drill a small pilot marker hole using your board bolt holes as the template. Remove from board and check the holes have 105 mm centres. Then scribe/draw a guideline down the side of the base section at 80 degrees to the fillet, similar to what you have done with the white lines above, in line with your pilot holes. Then drill a full depth pilot, check you are vertically placed in the base and 80 degrees to the fillet at frequent intervals.
When complete, at approx 8mm up from the fillet drill a barrel nut pilot through the base sideways - it must intersect with your bolt hole perfectly in the middle. Check that the barrel nut holes have 105 mm centres. If all good, drill full depth bolt hole making sure you stay on the 80 degree alignment and follow with barrel nut hole.
Power box - drill the bolt holt at 90 degrees to fillet base as per above.

remery
WA, 3384 posts
11 Jan 2021 2:19PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
olskool said..
^ Thanks Remery. Hmmm.. I hadn't thought that the barrel nuts would end up too thick for PB/Tuttle application. Lucky ive drilled no holes yet.
Guess if I put barrel nuts closer to mounting flange it'll cut down the amount of grinding needed.
Also need longer Fangyfin specific bolts for each board.
All good thanks!


The barrel nuts I had were too wide to fit in the tuttle box width-wize.

I don't have a jig or drill press so made a complete mess of mine. I would post a photo but it is a sight so disgusting I would probably get banned by Seabreeze, and Fangman would never sell me another fin. It does work though.

olskool
QLD, 2455 posts
11 Jan 2021 4:54PM
Thumbs Up

Fangy, I've not got a protractor or angle-ometer.
So 90deg to upper powerbox base cut out will give me 80deg to fin fillet flange?
Remery, don't worry ive got no drill press either, n no workbench. Using the local parkbenches for my Fangy Fiasco mods.

fangman
WA, 1774 posts
11 Jan 2021 6:39PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
olskool said..

So 90deg to upper powerbox base cut out will give me 80deg to fin fillet flange?




Sorry but No. From memory the angle of the powerbox base is something weird like 22.5 degrees from horizontal. You have to use your angle thingy and measure 80 degrees from the fillet base if you are making a universal box. ( and just to confuse the issue - you are correct in that it is 90 degrees from the top of a Tuttlebox base )

fangman
WA, 1774 posts
11 Jan 2021 8:16PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
olskool said..
Anyway I first attacked it with 40grit then 80grit flapper disc. Next was 180grit wet n dry. Then 360 grit wet n dry. Finished with wet green scourer. Any need to take it further?




Just noticed this one - 360 is fine. The experiments done so far suggest the higher polished surfaces have better lift, the lower polished foils have slighty low drag, but significantly lower lift.

olskool
QLD, 2455 posts
12 Jan 2021 4:51AM
Thumbs Up

I'm many hours into the FF28. Re polishing. So less lift equals less early planing?
Early planing is my best friend.
No planing equals no speed.

fangman
WA, 1774 posts
12 Jan 2021 8:51AM
Thumbs Up

TBH the power of the FF28 foil is such that I think the surface finish will make very little noticeable difference to early planing ability. What you have already done will be good.
In the most basic sense, More lift = early planing, but because nothing is that simple, More lift = More drag = slower top speed. It's always a trade off to some degree.

YP1
SA, 134 posts
18 Jan 2021 1:50PM
Thumbs Up

Sounds like Old School & Remery got lessons from Tricky
BTY I just drill & tap dont worry about barrel nuts
Put the fin in the board mark, center punch put back in board drill pilot hole.........



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing   Gps and Speed talk


"FangyFin DIY help, hints and show us ya fin page" started by fangman