Forums > Windsurfing Gear Reviews

North 3Di

Reply
Created by forsyth > 9 months ago, 29 Jan 2023
duzzi
1074 posts
27 Aug 2023 11:29PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Manuel7 said..
Yoo-hoo, quick 1-2 month update on my buddy's 5.0 and 5.8.

He loves the sails, really happy with them and their light weight.

On one (he has 2) the downhaul ripped and had to be repaired. He chose the conventional repair route. The batten tensioners seem a little fragile or brittle. They will break under heavy load.

No other issue to report.


Not to beat a dead horse but ... a downhaul ripped after two months ...

Imax1
QLD, 4810 posts
28 Aug 2023 6:06AM
Thumbs Up

To be fair , I wonder if he got dumped in waves or it just happened ?

jdfoils
268 posts
28 Aug 2023 9:54AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Imax1 said..
To be fair , I wonder if he got dumped in waves or it just happened ?


Shouldn't tempt fate, but I've Been rolled many time with my Ezzys and never ripped out a downhaul grommet...

philn
904 posts
28 Aug 2023 11:10AM
Thumbs Up

I've broken a brass downhaul pulley, but the strap it was in was fine so I bought another pulley and was sailing again by the following weekend.

Manuel7
1274 posts
28 Aug 2023 12:47PM
Thumbs Up

After 1 month and since it's his small sail prob under 20 sessions. Small waves here in summer.

The clew looks good. Let's see how they do through one winter. Lots of sun here too.

sprayblaze
158 posts
29 Aug 2023 12:07AM
Thumbs Up

From all that I have read up until now about these sails I consider a waste of time, another needless innovation.

philn
904 posts
29 Aug 2023 12:50AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
sprayblaze said..
From all that I have read up until now about these sails I consider a waste of time, another needless innovation.


I disagree, I think they're pushing the other brands to improve. Hot Sails Maui now has the Lithium which is claimed to be as light as these sails.

philn
904 posts
29 Aug 2023 12:52AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
sprayblaze said..
From all that I have read up until now about these sails I consider a waste of time, another needless innovation.


I think a lot (all?) of the problems we've read about in this thread are pretty easy for North to fix. So the next version could be everything this version promised.

sheddweller
268 posts
29 Aug 2023 4:53AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
philn said..


sprayblaze said..
From all that I have read up until now about these sails I consider a waste of time, another needless innovation.




I disagree, I think they're pushing the other brands to improve. Hot Sails Maui now has the Lithium which is claimed to be as light as these sails.



It's very very easy to build lightweight sails.
It is not quite as easy to build lightweight sails that can last for more than 5 minutes or can take a beating at cloudbreak.

Lahni
11 posts
30 Aug 2023 3:48PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
sheddweller said..

philn said..



sprayblaze said..
From all that I have read up until now about these sails I consider a waste of time, another needless innovation.





I disagree, I think they're pushing the other brands to improve. Hot Sails Maui now has the Lithium which is claimed to be as light as these sails.




It's very very easy to build lightweight sails.
It is not quite as easy to build lightweight sails that can last for more than 5 minutes or can take a beating at cloudbreak.


man North Sails are incredible! so Light in your Hands, coming from Duotone and very happy now switch to NS the whole Range Wave and Race Sails.

the Xover is even a good Sail for freestyling and racing has never been so comfortable!



Manawa
138 posts
6 Sep 2023 5:23PM
Thumbs Up

Hi guys, I've used this sail (Wave Clear 4.7) from april to July in Garda Lake and than in Agoust I've used it in Mauritius ripping Oneye, Manawa, Little Reef. I use the Ultimate rdm 370 mast (made in Australia), and the North Carbon extention.
The test will be very short:
1) Magic, Amazing, Legend sail
2) Yes a New era is open.
3) Best sail than ever in our sport.

Stop

Lahni
11 posts
9 Sep 2023 2:16AM
Thumbs Up

I hope there will be a freestyle / foil freestyle sail, it would be the lightest in all of sailmaking! And weight makes a big difference in foiling and freestyle moves....

JonnoR
18 posts
14 Sep 2023 3:32AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote

As a sailmaker I must voice my concern regarding the materials durability. It's true the material is light, strong and holds its shape fairly well however it gains nothing in durability. Instead of creasing and breaking like monofilm/mylar it becomes porous as if you poked it with a sewing needle. Had they really come up with a jack of all trades sailcloth, every cruising sailboat would be running 3di sails, instead it's only the racers and they are changing their inventory quite often.

If they make the skin thicker and properly design it, it could very well be the best sail on the market but I always fear planned obsolescence.


I think the 3di raw mainsails on the 60s should answer your concerns, some of these have done 2 laps of the globe! For sure with a lot more laminate but amazing all the same.

JonnoR
18 posts
14 Sep 2023 3:42AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Gwarn said..
Coming from the Ezzy Taka wave sail to the 3Di the taka has far more range then 3Di that I'm using.
The ezzy you can have a full low draft or a flat high draft using the downhaul and outhaul.
The 3di that I use has very little downhaul adjustment. (wave sail)
I have over 100 days 200+ hours on mine.
It's lite yes +++++++
It's slowing fading and turning white.-------
With the north mast it was $1500 USD
I'll use it this summer in the bay area and then this coming winter in baja I'll put 200+ more days on it if I'm lucky before I turn it into a drop cloth. We will see....
It's going to be different for everybody it's just sail that is lite with a lite mast.

You guys can bang your D_ck_ all day long about this and that butt in the end it's just a windsurfing sail.

This is all FACTS not me dumping on it

You can look in my profile at the pictures............


A quick question
I have the Xover 5.8 and 5.0 but get excessive leech flutter when foiling with these. Obviously I have tried all combination of downhaul/outhaul. On the fin they are fantastic
cheers
j

Gwarn
232 posts
15 Sep 2023 10:05PM
Thumbs Up

Ya I have the same problem with the flutter. It's a trade off for me I found if I run it fuller with less downhaul it's not as bad. I also use the factory mast.
As for the batten repair North payed for it so I'm using it again 10 day or so.
I'm going to wait to replace it to see if they make any changes as I don't think Gen1 3.7 wave sail (Beta Test) is worth $980.00 USD knowing it's short coming.
I do love how lite it is......

duzzi
1074 posts
16 Sep 2023 12:54AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
JonnoR said..





As a sailmaker I must voice my concern regarding the materials durability. It's true the material is light, strong and holds its shape fairly well however it gains nothing in durability. Instead of creasing and breaking like monofilm/mylar it becomes porous as if you poked it with a sewing needle. Had they really come up with a jack of all trades sailcloth, every cruising sailboat would be running 3di sails, instead it's only the racers and they are changing their inventory quite often.
If they make the skin thicker and properly design it, it could very well be the best sail on the market but I always fear planned obsolescence.





I think the 3di raw mainsails on the 60s should answer your concerns, some of these have done 2 laps of the globe! For sure with a lot more laminate but amazing all the same.




3Di or not there is no relationship between the construction requirement of a round the globe 60s mainsail and that of recreational wave sail. North, like any other sailmaker, could build their sails to last for decades, or build them to last two days. From the limited data set presented here, it clearly tilted toward "two days". Generation 2 could easily be built stronger, but then it would be heavier, there is no free lunch.

BTW: North just released the foil racing sail. Of course with the fake advertisement: "Remarkably lightweight".
Fake because they finally posted the weights and as expected the sails weight as much as any racing sail on the market. 5.5, 6.5, 7.5, 8,5 coming in at 5, 5.4, 5.8, and 6.2 Kg, are right in the middle between the Point-7 (heavier) and the Severne hyperglide (lighter, by a good chunk!).

sheddweller
268 posts
16 Sep 2023 1:26AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
duzzi said..

JonnoR said..






As a sailmaker I must voice my concern regarding the materials durability. It's true the material is light, strong and holds its shape fairly well however it gains nothing in durability. Instead of creasing and breaking like monofilm/mylar it becomes porous as if you poked it with a sewing needle. Had they really come up with a jack of all trades sailcloth, every cruising sailboat would be running 3di sails, instead it's only the racers and they are changing their inventory quite often.
If they make the skin thicker and properly design it, it could very well be the best sail on the market but I always fear planned obsolescence.






I think the 3di raw mainsails on the 60s should answer your concerns, some of these have done 2 laps of the globe! For sure with a lot more laminate but amazing all the same.





3Di or not there is no relationship between the construction requirement of a round the globe 60s mainsail and that of recreational wave sail. North, like any other sailmaker, could build their sails to last for decades, or build them to last two days. From the limited data set presented here, it clearly tilted toward "two days". Generation 2 could easily be built stronger, but then it would be heavier, there is no free lunch.

BTW: North just released the foil racing sail. Of course with the fake advertisement: "Remarkably lightweight".
Fake because they finally posted the weights and as expected the sails weight as much as any racing sail on the market. 5.5, 6.5, 7.5, 8,5 coming in at 5, 5.4, 5.8, and 6.2 Kg, are right in the middle between the Point-7 (heavier) and the Severne hyperglide (lighter, by a good chunk!).


Ridiculously heavy. The question must be asked, do they know what they are doing?

choco
SA, 4073 posts
16 Sep 2023 5:27AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
duzzi said..

JonnoR said..






As a sailmaker I must voice my concern regarding the materials durability. It's true the material is light, strong and holds its shape fairly well however it gains nothing in durability. Instead of creasing and breaking like monofilm/mylar it becomes porous as if you poked it with a sewing needle. Had they really come up with a jack of all trades sailcloth, every cruising sailboat would be running 3di sails, instead it's only the racers and they are changing their inventory quite often.
If they make the skin thicker and properly design it, it could very well be the best sail on the market but I always fear planned obsolescence.






I think the 3di raw mainsails on the 60s should answer your concerns, some of these have done 2 laps of the globe! For sure with a lot more laminate but amazing all the same.





3Di or not there is no relationship between the construction requirement of a round the globe 60s mainsail and that of recreational wave sail. North, like any other sailmaker, could build their sails to last for decades, or build them to last two days. From the limited data set presented here, it clearly tilted toward "two days". Generation 2 could easily be built stronger, but then it would be heavier, there is no free lunch.

BTW: North just released the foil racing sail. Of course with the fake advertisement: "Remarkably lightweight".
Fake because they finally posted the weights and as expected the sails weight as much as any racing sail on the market. 5.5, 6.5, 7.5, 8,5 coming in at 5, 5.4, 5.8, and 6.2 Kg, are right in the middle between the Point-7 (heavier) and the Severne hyperglide (lighter, by a good chunk!).


They should have used regular cam system, the air cams must weigh a bit

ausbinny
169 posts
16 Sep 2023 7:17AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
sheddweller said..

duzzi said..


JonnoR said..







As a sailmaker I must voice my concern regarding the materials durability. It's true the material is light, strong and holds its shape fairly well however it gains nothing in durability. Instead of creasing and breaking like monofilm/mylar it becomes porous as if you poked it with a sewing needle. Had they really come up with a jack of all trades sailcloth, every cruising sailboat would be running 3di sails, instead it's only the racers and they are changing their inventory quite often.
If they make the skin thicker and properly design it, it could very well be the best sail on the market but I always fear planned obsolescence.







I think the 3di raw mainsails on the 60s should answer your concerns, some of these have done 2 laps of the globe! For sure with a lot more laminate but amazing all the same.






3Di or not there is no relationship between the construction requirement of a round the globe 60s mainsail and that of recreational wave sail. North, like any other sailmaker, could build their sails to last for decades, or build them to last two days. From the limited data set presented here, it clearly tilted toward "two days". Generation 2 could easily be built stronger, but then it would be heavier, there is no free lunch.

BTW: North just released the foil racing sail. Of course with the fake advertisement: "Remarkably lightweight".
Fake because they finally posted the weights and as expected the sails weight as much as any racing sail on the market. 5.5, 6.5, 7.5, 8,5 coming in at 5, 5.4, 5.8, and 6.2 Kg, are right in the middle between the Point-7 (heavier) and the Severne hyperglide (lighter, by a good chunk!).



Ridiculously heavy. The question must be asked, do they know what they are doing?


So the Point 7's are super Ridiculously heavy???

jdfoils
268 posts
16 Sep 2023 8:49AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
do they know what they are doing?


Absolutely. Separating sailors from their $ is there core competency.

2keen
WA, 365 posts
16 Sep 2023 10:38AM
Thumbs Up

There is a lot of talk here about the weight of the 3Di North sails and it's my opinion that any company has to be wary claiming to be the lightest, or fastest for that matter, because weight and speed are easily measured.
I am using the North Wave Clear sails for foiling and when weighed they are light. I am however continually impressed by how light they "feel" on the water. I'm sure this is achieved by placing more fibres in high load points like foot, clew and luff and less in the head and leech.

sprayblaze
158 posts
16 Sep 2023 2:07PM
Thumbs Up

My wave sails are scrim laminates and I don't intend changing them anytime soon. I am not buying this bla-bla "lightweight", "smart", "i","3D" etc.. Now that the legendary Fanatic brand is gone I am disgusted and buying a gloomy black sail for a fortune is the last thing on my agenda.

sheddweller
268 posts
16 Sep 2023 5:58PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
ausbinny said..

sheddweller said..


duzzi said..



JonnoR said..








As a sailmaker I must voice my concern regarding the materials durability. It's true the material is light, strong and holds its shape fairly well however it gains nothing in durability. Instead of creasing and breaking like monofilm/mylar it becomes porous as if you poked it with a sewing needle. Had they really come up with a jack of all trades sailcloth, every cruising sailboat would be running 3di sails, instead it's only the racers and they are changing their inventory quite often.
If they make the skin thicker and properly design it, it could very well be the best sail on the market but I always fear planned obsolescence.








I think the 3di raw mainsails on the 60s should answer your concerns, some of these have done 2 laps of the globe! For sure with a lot more laminate but amazing all the same.







3Di or not there is no relationship between the construction requirement of a round the globe 60s mainsail and that of recreational wave sail. North, like any other sailmaker, could build their sails to last for decades, or build them to last two days. From the limited data set presented here, it clearly tilted toward "two days". Generation 2 could easily be built stronger, but then it would be heavier, there is no free lunch.

BTW: North just released the foil racing sail. Of course with the fake advertisement: "Remarkably lightweight".
Fake because they finally posted the weights and as expected the sails weight as much as any racing sail on the market. 5.5, 6.5, 7.5, 8,5 coming in at 5, 5.4, 5.8, and 6.2 Kg, are right in the middle between the Point-7 (heavier) and the Severne hyperglide (lighter, by a good chunk!).




Ridiculously heavy. The question must be asked, do they know what they are doing?



So the Point 7's are super Ridiculously heavy???


Yep. There is no need for all this weight.
lightweight is 3.5kg 8m.

40FrothyKnots
NSW, 92 posts
18 Sep 2023 12:37PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
sheddweller said..

duzzi said..


JonnoR said..







As a sailmaker I must voice my concern regarding the materials durability. It's true the material is light, strong and holds its shape fairly well however it gains nothing in durability. Instead of creasing and breaking like monofilm/mylar it becomes porous as if you poked it with a sewing needle. Had they really come up with a jack of all trades sailcloth, every cruising sailboat would be running 3di sails, instead it's only the racers and they are changing their inventory quite often.
If they make the skin thicker and properly design it, it could very well be the best sail on the market but I always fear planned obsolescence.







I think the 3di raw mainsails on the 60s should answer your concerns, some of these have done 2 laps of the globe! For sure with a lot more laminate but amazing all the same.






3Di or not there is no relationship between the construction requirement of a round the globe 60s mainsail and that of recreational wave sail. North, like any other sailmaker, could build their sails to last for decades, or build them to last two days. From the limited data set presented here, it clearly tilted toward "two days". Generation 2 could easily be built stronger, but then it would be heavier, there is no free lunch.

BTW: North just released the foil racing sail. Of course with the fake advertisement: "Remarkably lightweight".
Fake because they finally posted the weights and as expected the sails weight as much as any racing sail on the market. 5.5, 6.5, 7.5, 8,5 coming in at 5, 5.4, 5.8, and 6.2 Kg, are right in the middle between the Point-7 (heavier) and the Severne hyperglide (lighter, by a good chunk!).



Ridiculously heavy. The question must be asked, do they know what they are doing




Severne Hyperglide 6
6.0 5.12 KG
7.0 5.49 KG

North Race
6.0 5.20 KG ( + 80 GR)
6.8 5.50 KG ( + 10 GR)

Point 7
6.0 5.4 KG ( + 280 GR)
7.0 5.9 KG (+ 400 GR)
Those are a good chunk heavier!

North has ~100 gr difference on the current benchmark sails in therm of weight but comes with much more solid construction and a true 3D profile thanks to the aircam.





bel29
311 posts
18 Sep 2023 10:51PM
Thumbs Up

I don't care too much about absolute weight, although it does matter of course at the margins, but no one here seems to talk about this year's Duotone Warp Foils which are by far the lightest foiling racing sails I've had. The biggest weight gain compared to last year's model came from the use of penta material from their wing line for the (massive) luff pocket. the weight gain is remarkable, and material looks and feels (and seems to hold up) great. no stretch at all. also interesting to note: despite the black material the mast doesn't heat up nearly as much as in the previous sails with the luff made mostly out of film (summers get really hot here).

duzzi
1074 posts
18 Sep 2023 11:15PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
40FrothyKnots said..








sheddweller said..









duzzi said..










JonnoR said..















As a sailmaker I must voice my concern regarding the materials durability. It's true the material is light, strong and holds its shape fairly well however it gains nothing in durability. Instead of creasing and breaking like monofilm/mylar it becomes porous as if you poked it with a sewing needle. Had they really come up with a jack of all trades sailcloth, every cruising sailboat would be running 3di sails, instead it's only the racers and they are changing their inventory quite often.
If they make the skin thicker and properly design it, it could very well be the best sail on the market but I always fear planned obsolescence.















I think the 3di raw mainsails on the 60s should answer your concerns, some of these have done 2 laps of the globe! For sure with a lot more laminate but amazing all the same.














3Di or not there is no relationship between the construction requirement of a round the globe 60s mainsail and that of recreational wave sail. North, like any other sailmaker, could build their sails to last for decades, or build them to last two days. From the limited data set presented here, it clearly tilted toward "two days". Generation 2 could easily be built stronger, but then it would be heavier, there is no free lunch.

BTW: North just released the foil racing sail. Of course with the fake advertisement: "Remarkably lightweight".
Fake because they finally posted the weights and as expected the sails weight as much as any racing sail on the market. 5.5, 6.5, 7.5, 8,5 coming in at 5, 5.4, 5.8, and 6.2 Kg, are right in the middle between the Point-7 (heavier) and the Severne hyperglide (lighter, by a good chunk!).











Ridiculously heavy. The question must be asked, do they know what they are doing












Severne Hyperglide 6
6.0 5.12 KG
7.0 5.49 KG

North Race
6.0 5.20 KG ( + 80 GR)
6.8 5.50 KG ( + 10 GR)

Point 7
6.0 5.4 KG ( + 280 GR)
7.0 5.9 KG (+ 400 GR)
Those are a good chunk heavier!

North has ~100 gr difference on the current benchmark sails in therm of weight but comes with much more solid construction and a true 3D profile thanks to the aircam.





Wow. After months or claiming that the sails are a weight game changer it turns out that the North sails are actually as heavy or heavier than others on the market, and so now North jumps into claiming a "more solid construction"? And forget about the dismal durability users' feedback on this thread! Bravo!

And here @bel29 is indeed what seems to be the weight leader of the pack

Duotone Warp Foil 2023:
5.4 4.6 Kg
6.4 5.0 Kg
7.5 5.5 Kg

ozzimark
54 posts
19 Sep 2023 12:57AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
sheddweller said..

Yep. There is no need for all this weight.
lightweight is 3.5kg 8m.



Curious which sail that is. Lightest I know in the larger sizes if the HSM SpeedFreak...

sheddweller
268 posts
19 Sep 2023 4:42AM
Thumbs Up

About 20 years ago, Boards mag UK tested an 8m 6 batten sail with 6 cams that weighed 2.9kg. It was made from Kevlar laminates.
Any claims of "game changing" lightweight that do not beat that are bull****.

Lahni
11 posts
26 Sep 2023 1:31AM
Thumbs Up

Not only the weight itself make diffrences, also how light does the sail feels in your hands is intresting

and North got it right to the point! Such playfull, controlable and fast Sails combined with smart technology and high tech Materials

that's exactly what we need in Windsurfing, someone who develops and knows what he is doing! Best Sails on the Market, huge windrange and very versatile, recommend everyone to try it!

also Carbonparts masts,booms, extensions are worth a look! Definitely high end quality

Manawa
138 posts
3 Oct 2023 11:45PM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Lahni said..
Not only the weight itself make diffrences, also how light does the sail feels in your hands is intresting

and North got it right to the point! Such playfull, controlable and fast Sails combined with smart technology and high tech Materials

that's exactly what we need in Windsurfing, someone who develops and knows what he is doing! Best Sails on the Market, huge windrange and very versatile, recommend everyone to try it!

also Carbonparts masts,booms, extensions are worth a look! Definitely high end quality




I love North Sail






Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing Gear Reviews


"North 3Di" started by forsyth